Brian grudgingly produces Carnivale for the gay and lesbian center. Justin and Ethan share a romantic evening followed by a not so romantic snob party. Debbie and Carl get closer while Ben and Michael discuss cohabitation.

Brian replaces Justin with an assortment of tricks and continues to pay his tuition. Michael and Justin fight over the future of Rage while Ted and Emmett have their first fight as lovers. Melanie and Lindsay can’t agree about having a second child.

Justin starts to get comfortable with life after Brian, despite Michael’s attempts to push him away from everyone. Brian sets Michael straight with explosive results. Ted plans an over the top first-time for Emmett with unexpected results.

Patrick and Matt discuss Season 2. Favorite characters, least favorite arcs, and a little bit of retroactive continuity in the shape of Ben Bruckner not disclosing his HIV status before hooking up with Brian at the White Party. 

Season 2 comes to a close with Justin having to choose between Brian and Ethan, just as the Rage release party takes off, leaving Michael caught in the middle. Ben considers going to Tibet for six months and Ted professes his love for Emmett.

Justin’s relationship with Ethan deepens while his relationship with Brian unravels thanks to Michael’s meddling. Ted realizes that his feelings for Emmett run deeper than friendship, and Debbie organizes the Liberty Balls in the Cops vs Queers bowling to

Ben is hospitalized after suffering a severe reaction to his HIV meds leaving Michael to step up as his protector. Justin and Ethan get romantic while Brian is oblivious to their budding relationship. Emmett tangles with the Shickel family lawyers.

Brian’s job is at risk forcing him to choose between his career and a week away with Justin. Melanie and Lindsay suffer from lesbian bed death until Leda comes up with a unique solution. Emmett’s inheritance is burning a hole in his pocket.

Michael throws a surprise birthday party for Ben, who reacts uncharacteristically. Tired of Brian’s lack of commitment, Justin steps out and falls for a violinist at his school. Ted meets Mr. Right.